不同筛查工具识别急诊患者安宁疗护需求准确性的Meta分析

doi:10.3761/j.issn.2096-7446.2024.05.007

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 目的评价常用的安宁疗护筛查工具识别急诊科患者安宁疗护需求的准确性。方法计算机检索中国知网、万方数据库、中国生物医学文献数据库、PubMed、Cochrane Library、Embase、CINAHL、Web of Science等数据库,从建库至2023年11月所有有关安宁疗护筛查工具应用于急诊科患者的研究,由2名研究者独立进行文献筛选、资料提取和文献质量评价,采用Stata 15.0软件对资料数据进行Meta分析。结果共纳入20篇文献,包含20 122例患者,一共涉及6种筛查工具,其中最常用的是惊讶问题（Surprise Questions,SQ）（n=9）,其次是急诊安宁疗护快速筛查工具（the Palliative Care and Rapid Emergency Screening,P-CaRES）（n=7）及急诊科姑息治疗和临终关怀需求筛查工具（the Screen for Palliative and End-of-life care needs in the Emergency Department,SPEED）（n=2）。9项研究通过评估SQ预测患者病死率从而确定安宁疗护需求,总体而言,SQ预测病死率的敏感度为0.72（0.59,0.82）,特异度为0.74（0.62,0.84）,均为中等。SQ预测长期病死率（1年内、2年内）的敏感度0.75（0.64,0.84）高于预测短期病死率（1个月内、3个月内）的敏感度0.65（0.35,0.86）。此外,就1年内急诊入院或频繁急诊科就诊而言,SQ敏感度为0.72（0.41,0.90）、特异度为0.52（0.32,0.72）。P-CaRES预测安宁疗护需求合并敏感度为0.73（0.57,0.85）、特异度为0.64（0.48,0.77）。结论用于急诊科安宁疗护筛查的工具中SQ应用最广泛,其次是P-CaRES,两种工具在预测患者未来1年病死率方面均具有中等敏感度和特异度,但该结论仍需高质量、大样本研究进一步验证。

关键词: 急诊科, 疾病终末期, 安宁疗护, 筛查工具, Meta分析, 循证护理学

Abstract: Objective To evaluate the accuracy of commonly used hospice screening tools to identify hospice needs of emergency department patients. Methods We searched CNKI,Wanfang Database,China Biomedical Literature Database,PubMed,Cochrane Library,Embase,CINAHL,and Web of Science for all studies on hospice screening tools applied to emergency department patients from the time of database construction to November 2023,and two researchers independently performed literature screening,data extraction,and literature quality evaluation,and Stata 15.0 software was used to perform meta-analysis of the profile data. Results A total of 20 papers were included,containing 20,122 patients,involving a total of 6 screening tools,of which the most commonly used was the Surprise Questions（SQ;n=9）,followed by the Palliative Care and Rapid Emergency Screening（P-CaRES;n=7） and the Screen for Palliative and End-of-life care needs in the Emergency Department（SPEED;n=2）. 9 studies identified hospice needs by assessing the SQ for predicting patient mortality. Overall,the sensitivity of the SQ for predicting mortality was moderate at 0.72（0.59,0.82） and the specificity was moderate at 0.74（0.62,0.84）.The sensitivity of the SQ for predicting long-term mortality（within 1 year,2 years） was higher at 0.75（0.64,0.84） than the sensitivity of the SQ for predicting short-term mortality（within 1 month,within 3 months） of 0.65（0.35,0.86）. In addition,for emergency admissions or frequent emergency department visits within 1 year,SQ sensitivity was 0.72（0.41,0.90） and specificity was 0.52（0.32,0.72）.P-CaRES predicted mortality with a sensitivity of 0.73（0.57,0.85） and specificity of 0.64（0.48,0.77）. Conclusion The SQ is the most widely used tool for hospice screening in the emergency department,followed by the P-CaRES,and they both have moderate sensitivity and specificity in predicting patient mortality in the next one year,the conclusion that still requires further validation in high-quality,large-sample studies.

Key words: Emergency Department, End-of-Life, Palliative Care, Screening Tool, Meta-Analysis, Evidence-Based Nursing

李白玉, 高薇薇, 张珠凤, 李柯叶, 邓亚银. 不同筛查工具识别急诊患者安宁疗护需求准确性的Meta分析[J]. 中华急危重症护理杂志, 2024, 5(5): 427-434.

LI Baiyu, GAO Weiwei, ZHANG Zhufeng, LI Keye, DENG Yayin. Accuracy of different screening tools for identifying hospice needs in emergency department patients：a meta-analysis[J]. Chinese Journal of Emergency and Critical Care Nursing, 2024, 5(5): 427-434.

参考文献

[1] Knaul FM,Farmer PE,Krakauer EL,et al.Alleviating the access abyss in palliative care and pain relief-an imperative of uni-versal health coverage:the Lancet Commission report[J]. Lancet,2018,391(10128):1391-1454.
[2] 雷蕾,徐霞,林莉,等. 临终患者死亡质量的研究现状及启示[J]. 护理学杂志,2018,33(18):107-110.
Lei L,Xu X,Lin L,et al.Research progress on quality of death and dying in end of life patients:implication for clinical practice[J]. J Nurs Sci,2018,33(18):107-110.
[3] Grudzen CR,Richardson LD,Morrison M,et al.Palliative care needs of seriously ill,older adults presenting to the emergency department[J]. Acad Emerg Med,2010,17(11):1253-1257.
[4] Amado-Tineo JP,Oscanoa-Espinoza T,Vásquez-Alva R,et al.Emergency department use by terminally ill patients:a systematic review[J]. J Pain Symptom Manage,2021,61(3):531-543.
[5] Liberman T,Kozikowski A,Kwon N,et al.Identifying advanced illness patients in the emergency department and having goals-of-care discussions to assist with early hospice referral[J]. J Emerg Med,2018,54(2):191-197.
[6] Chung H,Harding R,Guo P.Palliative care in the greater China region:a systematic review of needs,models,and outcomes[J]. J Pain Symptom Manage,2021,61(3):585-612.
[7] 柯菊青,袁玲,黄亦萱,等. 三级甲等综合医院急诊安宁疗护的实施与效果评价[J]. 中国护理管理,2022,22(2):305-309.
Ke JQ,Yuan L,Huang YX,et al.Application and effects evaluation of palliative care in the emergency department in a tertiary hospital[J]. Chin Nurs Manag,2022,22(2):305-309.
[8] Hendin A,La Rivière CG,Williscroft DM,et al.End-of-life care in the emergency department for the patient imminently dying of a highly transmissible acute respiratory infection(such as COVID-19)[J]. CJEM,2020,22(4):414-417.
[9] Fusi-Schmidhauser T,Preston NJ,Keller N,et al.Conservative management of COVID-19 patients-emergency palliative care in action[J]. J Pain Symptom Manage,2020,60(1):e27-e30.
[10] Whiting PF,Rutjes AWS,Westwood ME,et al.QUADAS-2:a revised tool for the quality assessment of diagnostic accuracy studies[J]. Ann Intern Med,2011,155(8):529-536.
[11] Lijmer JG,Bossuyt PM,Heisterkamp SH.Exploring sources of heterogeneity in systematic reviews of diagnostic tests[J]. Stat Med,2002,21(11):1525-1537.
[12] Corrêa da Costa Ribeiro S,Tavares de Carvalho R,Aparecida Rocha J,et al. Criterion validity and inter-rater reliability of a palliative care screening tool for patients admitted to an emer-gency department intensive care unit[J]. Palliat Support Care, 2018,16(6):685-691.
[13] Haydar SA,Strout TD,Bond AG,et al.Prognostic value of a modified surprise question designed for use in the emergency department setting[J]. Clin Exp Emerg Med,2019,6(1):70-76.
[14] Ouchi K,Jambaulikar G,George NR,et al. The “surprise question” asked of emergency physicians may predict 12-month mortality among older emergency department patients[J]. J Palliat Med,2018,21(2):236-240.
[15] Aaronson EL,George N,Ouchi K,et al.The surprise question can be used to identify heart failure patients in the emergency department who would benefit from palliative care[J]. J Pain Symptom Manage,2019,57(5):944-951.
[16] Lakin JR,Robinson MG,Obermeyer Z,et al.Prioritizing primary care patients for a communication intervention using the “surprise question”:a prospective cohort study[J]. J Gen Intern Med,2019,34(8):1467-1474.
[17] Verhoef MJ,de Nijs EJM,Fiocco M,et al. Surprise question and performance status indicate urgency of palliative care needs in patients with advanced cancer at the emergency department:an observational cohort study[J]. J Palliat Med,2020,23(6):801-808.
[18] Tripp D,Janis J,Jarrett B,et al.How well does the surprise question predict 1-year mortality for patients admitted with COPD?[J]. J Gen Intern Med,2021,36(9):2656-2662.
[19] Gaffney L,Jonsson A,Judge C,et al.Using the "surprise question" to predict frailty and healthcare outcomes among older adults attending the emergency department[J]. Int J Environ Res Public Health,2022,19(3):1709.
[20] Koyavatin S,Liu SW,Sri-on J. A comparison of palliative care and rapid emergency screening(P-CaRES) tool,broad and narrow criteria,and surprise questions to predict survival of older emergency department patients[J]. BMC Palliat Care,2023,22(1):81.
[21] Yang C,Yang TT,Tsou YJ,et al.Initiating palliative care consultation for acute critically ill patients in the emergency department intensive care unit[J]. J Chin Med Assoc,2020,83(5):500-506.
[22] Paske JRT,DeWitt S,Hicks R,et al. Palliative care and rapid emergency screening tool and the palliative performance scale to predict survival of older adults admitted to the hospital from the emergency department[J]. Am J Hosp Palliat Care,2021,38(7):800-806.
[23] Hamill Howard E,Schwartz R,Feldstein B,et al.Harnessing the chaplain's capacity to identify unmet palliative needs of vulnerable older adults in the emergency department[J]. J Palliat Care,2022,37(4):480-485.
[24] Ouchi K,Block SD,Schonberg MA,et al.Feasibility testing of an emergency department screening tool to identify older adults appropriate for palliative care consultation[J]. J Palliat Med,2017,20(1):69-73.
[25] Köstenberger M,Neuwersch S,Weixler D,et al.Prevalence of palliative care patients in emergency departments[J]. Wien Klin Wochenschr,2019,131(17/18):404-409.
[26] Kirkland SW,Yang EH,Clua MG,et al.Comparison of the management and short-term outcomes between patients with advanced cancer and other end-of-life conditions presenting to two Canadian emergency departments[J]. J Palliat Med,2022,25(6):915-924.
[27] Richards CT,Gisondi MA,Chang CH,et al.Palliative care symptom assessment for patients with cancer in the emergency department:validation of the Screen for Palliative and End-of-life care needs in the emergency department instrument[J]. J Palliat Med,2011,14(6):757-764.
[28] Reuter Q,Marshall A,Zaidi H,et al.Emergency department-based palliative interventions:a novel approach to palliative care in the emergency department[J]. J Palliat Med,2019,22(6):649-655.
[29] Cotogni P,Luca AD,Evangelista A,et al.A simplified screening tool to identify seriously ill patients in the Emergency department for referral to a palliative care team[J]. Minerva Anestesiol,2017,83(5):474-484.
[30] Kruhlak M,Kirkland SW,Clua MG,et al.An assessment of the management of patients with advanced end-stage illness in the emergency department:an observational cohort study[J]. J Palliat Med,2021,24(12):1840-1848.
[31] Wang RF,Lai CC,Fu PY,et al.A-qCPR risk score screening model for predicting 1-year mortality associated with hospice and palliative care in the emergency department[J]. Palliat Med,2021,35(2):408-416.
[32] 王玫,李婉玲,乐霄,等. 加拿大安大略注册护士学会2020版《临终前12个月安宁疗护临床实践指南》解读[J]. 护理研究,2022,36(9):1505-1510.
Wang M,Li WL,Le X,et al.Interpretation of “Clinical practice guidelines for a palliative approach to caring the last 12 months of life(2020 edition)” by Registered Nurses' Association of Ontario[J]. Chin Nurs Res,2022,36(9):1505-1510.
[33] Kirkland SW,Yang EH,Garrido Clua M,et al.Screening tools to identify patients with unmet palliative care needs in the emergency department:a systematic review[J]. Acad Emerg Med,2022,29(10):1229-1246.
[34] Loffredo AJ,Chan GK,Wang DH,et al.United states best practice guidelines for primary palliative care in the emergency department[J]. Ann Emerg Med,2021,78(5):658-669.