基于早期预警评分启动快速反应小组的范围综述

doi:10.3761/j.issn.2096-7446.2024.11.008

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 目的对国内外基于早期预警评分启动快速反应小组（rapid response team,RRT）的应用效果进行范围综述。方法系统检索PubMed、Embase、Scopus、CINAHL、Web of Science、Cochrane Library、中国知网、维普数据库、万方数据库、中国生物医学数据库中相关文献,检索时限为建库至2024年3月31日,依据纳入排除标准对文献进行筛选及信息资料提取。结果共纳入文献24篇,其中中文3篇、英文21篇。总结了基于早期预警评分启动RRT在4个方面的内容：病情恶化的识别、RRT的启动情况、RRT的响应情况和评价指标。病情恶化的识别涉及评估时机和评分工具的选择;RRT的启动情况包括RRT的启动方和立即启动标准;RRT的响应情况包括RRT的组成和响应时间;评价指标涉及患者的临床结局和RRT启动现况。结论基于早期预警评分启动的RRT能及时识别患者病情恶化的迹象并进行干预,对改善患者临床结局方面具有积极作用;但国内应用尚处于初步探索阶段,需进一步的研究和实践来完善和优化。

关键词: 早期预警评分, 快速反应小组, 范围综述

Abstract: Objective To undertake a scoping review of the application research on the activation of Rapid Response Teams（RRT） for early warning scoring,both domestically and internationally. Methods We conducted a systematic search for relevant literatures in the following databases：PubMed,Embase,Scopus,CINAHL,Web of Science,The Cochrane Library,CNKI,VIP,WanFang,and CBM. The search period limited from the establishment of the database to March 31,2024,and the literature was screened and information materials were extracted based on the inclusion criteria. Results A total of 24 articles were included,including 3 in Chinese and 21 in English. We summarized the early warning score initiation of RRT in four areas：identification of deterioration,initiation of RRT,response to RRT,and evaluation metrics. Identification of deterioration involved timing of assessment and selection of scoring tools. RRT initiation scenarios included RRT initiator and immediate initiation criteria. The response profile of the RRT included the composition of the RRT and the response time. The evaluation metrics related to the clinical outcome of the patient and the current status of RRT initiation. Conclusion RRT initiated based on early warning scores can identify signs of deterioration in patients and intervene in a timely manner,which has a positive effects on improving the clinical outcomes of patients,but its application in China is still in the preliminary stage of exploration,and further research and practice are needed to improve and optimize it.

Key words: Early Warning Score, Rapid Response Team, Scoping Review

陶思莹, 邓作梅, 柯桂君, 刘月泉, 周康. 基于早期预警评分启动快速反应小组的范围综述[J]. 中华急危重症护理杂志, 2024, 5(11): 1007-1013.

TAO Siying, DENG Zuomei, KE Guijun, LIU Yuequan, ZHOU Kang. A scoping review of activating rapid response teams based on early warning scores[J]. Chinese Journal of Emergency and Critical Care Nursing, 2024, 5(11): 1007-1013.

参考文献

[1] Brink A,Alsma J,Verdonschot RJCG,et al.Predicting mortality in patients with suspected sepsis at the Emergency Department;A retrospective cohort study comparing qSOFA,SIRS and National Early Warning Score[J]. PLoS One,2019,14(1):e0211133.
[2] Kim SH,Hong JY,Kim Y.Characteristics and prognosis of hospitalized patients at high risk of deterioration identified by the rapid response system:a multicenter cohort study[J]. J Korean Med Sci,2021,36(32):e235.
[3] 实用休克杂志(中英文)编委会,湖南省复苏质量控制中心. 医院内急诊重症快速反应小组建设专家共识[J]. 实用休克杂志(中英文),2023,7(2):109-114.
Editorial Board of Practical Shock Journal,Hunan Resuscitation Quality Control Center. Expert consensus on the construction of emergency severe rapid response team in hospital[J]. J Pract Shock,2023,7(2):109-114.
[4] 褚汉卿,胡娟娟,陆雯. 院内快速反应小组对住院患者心跳呼吸骤停事件的干预效果分析[J]. 现代实用医学,2022,34(11):1493-1495.
Chu HQ,Hu JJ,Lu W.Analysis on the intervention effect of rapid response team in hospital on cardiac arrest and respiratory arrest of inpatients[J]. Mod Pract Med,2022,34(11):1493-1495.
[5] Lockwood C,Tricco AC.Preparing scoping reviews for publication using methodological guides and reporting standards[J]. Nurs Health Sci,2020,22(1):1-4.
[6] Liaw WJ,Wu TJ,Huang LH,et al.Effectiveness of implement-ing modified early warning system and rapid response team for general ward inpatients[J]. J Med Syst,2024,48(1):35.
[7] Kwantong C,Sutherasan Y,Junhasavasdikul D,et al.Effect of the ramathibodi rapid response system triggered by the ramathibodi early warning score and clinical warning signs on in-hospital mortality and the incidence of cardiopulmonary resuscitation in adult hospitalized patients[J]. Ther Clin Risk Manag,2023,19:1025-1038.
[8] 徐兰娟,安婷婷. 重症快速拓展团队对病情变化住院患者结局的影响[J]. 中国医院管理,2022,42(8):57-60.
Xu LJ,An TT.The impact of the critical rapid outreach team on the outcome of hospitalized patients[J]. Chin Hosp Manag,2022,42(8):57-60.
[9] 黄冰瑛,唐佳迎,宋剑平,等. 智能早期预警评分系统对非重症患者预后评估的价值研究[J]. 中华急诊医学杂志,2022,31(9):1243-1248.
Huang BY,Tang JY,Song JP,et al.Effect of intelligent early warning scoring system in condition monitoring of hospitalized non-critically ill patients[J]. Chin J Emerg Med,2022,31(9):1243-1248.
[10] Ahmed M,Sarwer F,Gunjan,et al. Evaluation of automated alert and activation of medical emergency team in head and neck cancer patients using early warning score at tertiary level hospital in North India[J]. Cureus,2022,14(11):e31428.
[11] Suhr K,Steen C,Albrecht-Thompson R,et al.NEWS scoring system:use in hematologic malignancies and cellular therapeutics patient populations[J]. Clin J Oncol Nurs,2020,24(2):E21-E27.
[12] Heller AR,Mees ST,Lauterwald B,et al.Detection of deteriorating patients on surgical wards outside the ICU by an automated MEWS-based early warning system with paging functionality[J]. Ann Surg,2020,271(1):100-105.
[13] Douglas K,Collado JC,Keller S.Implementation of a pediatric early warning scoring system at an academic medical center[J]. Crit Care Nurs Q,2016,39(4):363-370.
[14] Mathukia C,Fan WQ,Vadyak K,et al.Modified Early Warning System improves patient safety and clinical outcomes in an academic community hospital[J]. J Community Hosp Intern Med Perspect,2015,5(2):26716.
[15] Panesar R,Polikoff LA,Harris D,et al.Characteristics and outcomes of pediatric rapid response teams before and after mandatory triggering by an elevated Pediatric Early Warning System(PEWS) score[J]. Hosp Pediatr,2014,4(3):135-140.
[16] Bokhari SW,Munir T,Memon S,et al.Impact of critical care reconfiguration and track-and-trigger outreach team intervention on outcomes of haematology patients requiring intensive care admission[J]. Ann Hematol,2010,89(5):505-512.
[17] Peek KN,Gillham M.Is the New Zealand Early Warning Score useful following cardiac surgery?[J]. N Z Med J,2017,130(1461):9-14.
[18] Alves Silva LM,Moroço DM,Pintya JP,et al.Clinical impact of implementing a rapid-response team based on the Modified Early Warning Score in wards that offer emergency department support[J]. PLoS One,2021,16(11):e0259577.
[19] Penney SW,O‘Hara-Wood SN,McFarlan LM,et al. A quality improvement initiative to reduce unnecessary rapid responses using early warning scores[J]. Pediatrics,2021,147(3):e20191 947.
[20] Na SJ,Ko RE,Ko MG,et al.Automated alert and activation of medical emergency team using early warning score[J]. J Intensive Care,2021,9(1):73.
[21] Ashbeck R,Stellpflug C,Ihrke E,et al.Development of a standardized system to detect and treat early patient deterioration[J]. J Nurs Care Qual,2021,36(1):32-37.
[22] 虞立,姜金霞,王春英,等. 快速反应小组的构建及运行效果研究[J]. 护理管理杂志,2017,17(11):847-849.
Yu L,Jiang JX,Wang CY,et al.Establishment and operating effectiveness research of the rapid response team[J]. J Nurs Adm,2017,17(11):847-849.
[23] Mullany DV,Ziegenfuss M,Goleby MA,et al.Improved hospital mortality with a low MET dose:the importance of a modified early warning score and communication tool[J]. Anaesth Intensive Care,2016,44(6):734-741.
[24] Ludikhuize J,Brunsveld-Reinders AH,Dijkgraaf MG,et al.Outcomes associated with the nationwide introduction of rapid response systems in the Netherlands[J]. Crit Care Med,2015,43(12):2544-2551.
[25] Ullah E,Albrett J,Khan O,et al.Workload involved in vital signs-based monitoring & responding to deteriorating patients:a single site experience from a regional New Zealand hospital[J]. Heliyon,2022,8(10):e10955.
[26] Singh S,Laud PW,Crotty BH,et al.Effect of implementing a commercial electronic early warning system on outcomes of hospitalized patients[J]. Am J Med Qual,2023,38(5):229-237.
[27] Miles I,Anderson M,Ren DX,et al.Use of the modified early warning score by medical-surgical nurses to initiate the rapid response team:impact on patient outcomes[J]. J Nurs Care Qual,2023,38(2):171-176.
[28] Heal M,Silvest-Guerrero S,Kohtz C.Design and development of a proactive rapid response system[J]. Comput Inform Nurs,2017,35(2):77-83.
[29] Bonafide CP,Localio AR,Roberts KE,et al.Impact of rapid response system implementation on critical deterioration events in children[J]. JAMA Pediatr,2014,168(1):25-33.
[30] Petersen JA.Early warning score challenges and opportunities in the care of deteriorating patients[J]. Dan Med J,2018,65(2):B5439.
[31] 陈芳,祝益民. 构建医院内急诊重症快速反应系统与快速反应小组[J]. 实用休克杂志(中英文),2023,7(2):65-67.
Chen F,Zhu YM.Constructing a rapid response system and rapid response team for emergency treatment in hospitals[J]. J Pract Shock,2023,7(2):65-67.
[32] Saab A,Abi Khalil C,Jammal M,et al.Early prediction of all-cause clinical deterioration in general wards patients:development and validation of a biomarker-based machine learning model derived from rapid response team activations[J]. J Patient Saf,2022,18(6):578-586.